Asphalt shingles cost less today; a standing seam metal roof usually costs less over 40 years. In Houston, the right choice depends on how long you plan to stay, how often your area sees hail, your HOA and your budget.
Here is a side-by-side look for Houston homeowners.
Need a roofer in Houston now?
Call to get connected with an available local roofing contractor for repairs, replacements and storm damage.
This line is run by our call partner and connects you with an available roofing company in your area. It is not the phone line for any company listed on this page.
Head-To-Head
Factor
Asphalt Shingles
Standing Seam Metal
Installed cost (typical home)
About $9,000 to $20,000
About $18,000 to $42,000
Lifespan in Houston
15 to 25 years
40+ years
Heat and cooling
Absorbs heat unless cool-rated
Reflective coatings lower attic heat
Hail
Class 4 versions resist well
Resists punctures; large hail can dent
Hurricane wind
Good with high-wind installation
Very good with concealed fasteners
Insurance
Class 4 discount available
Often qualifies for discounts too
Noise
Quiet
Quiet with solid decking
HOA acceptance
Almost always allowed
Check your deed restrictions
When Shingles Make More Sense
You plan to sell within 10 years
Your HOA restricts metal
You want the lowest upfront cost, or insurance is paying for a like-for-like replacement
You prefer a traditional look
When Metal Makes More Sense
You plan to stay 15 years or more
You want lower cooling bills and fewer roof replacements
Your area sees frequent wind events
You want a roof that will likely outlast the mortgage
What About Hail?
Metal sheds hail without the granule loss shingles suffer, but big stones can leave cosmetic dents. Some insurers exclude cosmetic damage on metal roofs, so read your policy. Class 4 shingles are a strong middle ground in hail-heavy suburbs.
Our Take
For long-term owners, metal is usually the better value in Houston’s climate. For shorter horizons or tight HOAs, Class 4 architectural shingles give most of the storm protection at half the price. Either way, choose a contractor certified in the system you pick; see our Best Roofers In Houston.
Need a roofer in Houston now?
Call to get connected with an available local roofing contractor for repairs, replacements and storm damage.
This line is run by our call partner and connects you with an available roofing company in your area. It is not the phone line for any company listed on this page.
