Last updated: November 15, 2026
The best email archiving solutions for compliance in 2027 are Mimecast, Proofpoint, Smarsh, Global Relay and Barracuda. Smarsh and Global Relay are the specialists for financial services firms that must meet SEC and FINRA rules, Mimecast and Proofpoint are the strongest choices when you also want email security, and Microsoft Purview is the right starting point for companies that only need basic retention inside Microsoft 365.
An email archive is a tamper-proof, searchable copy of every message your company sends and receives, kept for a set period to satisfy regulators, courts and auditors. It is different from a backup, which exists to restore lost data, and from continuity, which keeps mail flowing during an outage. But the three overlap. During the Microsoft 365 outage that began on November 12, 2026, companies with a third-party archive could still search and read their mail while Exchange Online was down, and some archive vendors also offer continuity.
Regulated firms have no choice here. Broker-dealers must preserve communications under SEC Rule 17a-4 and FINRA rules, and many other sectors face retention and eDiscovery duties. For everyone else, an archive is cheap insurance against lawsuits and lost mail.
| Company | Headquarters | Founded | Best For | Pricing |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mimecast | London, UK | 2003 | Archiving plus email security and continuity | Quote-based, per user |
| Proofpoint | Sunnyvale, CA | 2002 | Large and regulated enterprises | Quote-based |
| Smarsh | Portland, OR | 2001 | Financial services compliance | Quote-based |
| Global Relay | Vancouver, Canada | 1999 | Banks, brokers and capital markets | Quote-based |
| Barracuda Cloud Archiving Service | Campbell, CA | 2003 | Mid-market Microsoft 365 users | Per user, often bundled |
| Microsoft Purview | Redmond, WA | 1975 | Basic retention inside Microsoft 365 | Included in some licenses; advanced features in E5 or add-ons |
| Google Vault | Mountain View, CA | 1998 | Google Workspace customers | Included in Business Plus and Enterprise |
| MailStore | Viersen, Germany | 2004 | Small businesses wanting an on-premises archive | One-time license per user plus updates |
| Jatheon | Toronto, Canada | 2004 | Public sector and education | Quote-based |
| Hornetsecurity | Hanover, Germany | 2007 | SMBs wanting archiving in a security bundle | Per user, bundled plans |
Mimecast’s cloud archive keeps an independent, immutable copy of your mail with fast search, legal hold and eDiscovery, and it sits alongside Mimecast’s email security gateway and continuity service. That trio is the most complete protection package for companies on Microsoft 365.
During an Exchange Online outage, Mimecast customers can read archived mail and, with the continuity add-on, keep sending and receiving. Pricing is quote-based and bundled, so compare the whole package rather than archiving alone.
Proofpoint Archive and its intelligent supervision tools serve large enterprises and financial firms that need to capture, review and supervise communications across email, collaboration and social channels. It integrates with Proofpoint’s market-leading email security.
Proofpoint is built for organizations with compliance teams and legal departments. Small businesses will find it more than they need.
Smarsh captures and archives email plus more than 100 other channels, including Teams, Slack, Zoom, text messages and WhatsApp, and adds AI-assisted supervision for compliance teams. It is widely used by broker-dealers, investment advisers, banks and insurers.
If your regulator can ask for every message an adviser sent on any channel, Smarsh is one of the two default choices, alongside Global Relay.
Global Relay runs its own infrastructure to archive email, chat, voice and mobile communications for financial institutions, with supervision, surveillance and eDiscovery tools. It is designed for SEC 17a-4, FINRA and global financial regulations.
Global Relay is especially strong with trading desks and capital markets firms that rely on Bloomberg chat and voice alongside email.
Barracuda archives Microsoft 365 mail, Teams and OneDrive content in its cloud with retention policies, legal hold and search, and it is often bundled with Barracuda’s email protection and backup.
It is a practical choice for mid-size companies that want compliance archiving without enterprise complexity or pricing.
Microsoft Purview provides retention policies, litigation hold, archive mailboxes and eDiscovery inside Microsoft 365. Many businesses already own these features through their existing licenses.
The limitation is that the archive lives inside the same service it protects. When Exchange Online is down, so is your archive, and regulated firms often need third-party capture to satisfy their regulators. Use Purview as a baseline, not as the whole answer.
Google Vault is Workspace’s built-in tool for retention, legal hold and eDiscovery across Gmail, Drive, Chat and Meet. It comes with Business Plus and Enterprise plans.
Like Purview, it is a good baseline but not an independent archive. Regulated Workspace customers usually add Smarsh or Global Relay.
MailStore Server is a long-established email archiving product that small and mid-size businesses install on their own server. It archives Microsoft 365, Exchange and IMAP mail with fast search and retention policies.
Because the archive sits on your premises, it stays searchable when cloud services fail. The trade-off is that you maintain the server.
Jatheon archives email, social media and text messages for public sector agencies, schools and regulated businesses, with tools for public records requests and eDiscovery. It offers cloud and on-premises options.
It is particularly strong for government bodies that must respond to records requests quickly.
Hornetsecurity, now part of Proofpoint, includes email archiving in its 365 Total Protection bundles along with spam and malware filtering, encryption, backup and continuity.
For small and mid-size businesses that want one bill for Microsoft 365 protection, it is one of the most complete and affordable packages, and it is popular with MSPs.
We compared each solution on what it captures (email only or chat, voice and mobile too), immutability and regulatory fit (including SEC 17a-4 and FINRA), search and eDiscovery, supervision tools, whether the archive stays available when Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace is down, and pricing model. We checked vendor sites in November 2026. Rankings are editorial and no vendor paid for a position. Our full method is on our research and ranking page.
Broker-dealers, investment advisers and banks need archives designed for SEC and FINRA rules, which points to Smarsh, Global Relay or Proofpoint. Other businesses mainly need retention and eDiscovery, which Mimecast, Barracuda or even Purview can cover.
If staff use Teams, Slack, text messages or WhatsApp for business, an email-only archive is not enough. Check channel coverage before you sign.
A built-in archive goes down when your mail service does. An independent archive stays searchable during an outage and gives auditors a copy the mail admin cannot alter.
Mimecast and Hornetsecurity bundle archiving with email security and continuity. That can be cheaper than buying three separate products.
An archive keeps a tamper-proof, searchable record of every message for compliance and legal discovery. A backup keeps restorable copies so you can recover lost or deleted data. Many companies need both.
Microsoft Purview retention and eDiscovery are enough for many businesses. Regulated financial firms and companies that need an independent copy usually add a third-party archive.
Only if the archive was outside Microsoft. Third-party cloud archives such as Mimecast stayed searchable while Exchange Online was down. Archives inside Microsoft 365 were unavailable with it.
It depends on your industry and country. Broker-dealers must keep many records for at least three to six years, and many companies keep email for seven years to cover tax and legal claims. Check with your legal counsel.
Smarsh and Global Relay are the best choices for financial firms, Mimecast and Proofpoint lead when you want archiving and security together, and Purview or Google Vault cover basic retention for everyone else. Whichever you choose, make sure the archive stays searchable when your mail platform does not.
Archiving works best alongside a Microsoft 365 backup and an email continuity service. See the Cybersecurity And IT Services hub for more.
Related reading: Best SaaS Backup Tools For Google Workspace And Salesforce, Top Microsoft 365 Security Consultants, Best Outlook Alternatives For Business Email.