Last updated: November 21, 2026
The best Shopify subscription and loyalty tools for 2027 are Recharge, the category standard that bought Skio in April 2026 to power more than 20,000 merchants, Smile.io, which runs over 100,000 loyalty programs, and LoyaltyLion for larger brands. Loop Subscriptions, Stay Ai, Rivo, Smartrr, Appstle and Yotpo Loyalty cover the rest of the market, from free plans to enterprise.
After Black Friday and Cyber Monday, the job is getting a second order. Subscriptions lock in replenishment, and loyalty points give one-time discount buyers a reason to come back at full price. This list mixes both, because most brands need one of each. For deeper single-category rankings, see our lists of Shopify subscription apps and loyalty and rewards apps for Shopify.
| Tool | Type | Best For | Standout |
|---|---|---|---|
| Recharge | Subscriptions | Established subscription brands | Combined with Skio, 20,000+ merchants |
| Skio | Subscriptions | High-volume DTC brands | Passwordless portal, build-a-box |
| Loop Subscriptions | Subscriptions | Growing brands focused on churn | Cancellation flows, 35+ integrations |
| Stay Ai | Subscriptions | Enterprise subscription programs | RetentionEngine churn prevention |
| Smile.io | Loyalty | Small and mid-size Shopify stores | 100,000+ active programs |
| LoyaltyLion | Loyalty | Mid-market and larger brands | Multi-store programs, deep data |
| Rivo | Loyalty | Brands that want design control | Shopify-native, ships updates weekly |
| Smartrr | Subscriptions and loyalty | Brands that want one app for both | Loyalty, referrals and memberships built in |
| Appstle | Subscriptions | Cost-conscious stores | 0% transaction fees, free plan |
| Yotpo Loyalty | Loyalty | Brands already on Yotpo | Shared data with reviews and SMS |
Recharge has been the default Shopify subscription app since 2014, with bundles, a customer portal, retention flows and an SDK for custom builds. On April 30, 2026 it acquired Skio for a reported $105 million, and together the two power more than 20,000 merchants and over $20 billion in annual GMV.
It offers a 60-day free trial, and its scale means almost every Shopify agency and retention tool integrates with it. For brands converting holiday buyers into subscribers, it is the safest long-term bet.
Skio built its following among fast-growing DTC brands with passwordless customer login, build-a-box subscriptions and fast feature releases. Since the April 2026 deal its Shopify listing reads Skio, a Recharge Company, and Recharge says nothing changes for current merchants for now.
Skio’s portal reduces cancellations by making it easy to skip, swap or delay rather than quit, which matters most in February when holiday subscribers decide whether to stay.
Loop Subscriptions focuses on keeping subscribers, with personalized cancellation flows that offer skips, swaps or discounts based on why someone wants to leave. It has a free plan, a Starter tier from $99 a month plus 1%, and more than 35 integrations.
Retention agencies such as Email Kong build subscription programs on it, so brands can find experienced help to run it.
Stay Ai is built for large subscription programs. Its RetentionEngine forecasts churn and triggers interventions before a subscriber cancels, and it handles complex billing and migration from other platforms.
Pricing starts at $499 a month plus 1% and 19 cents per order, so it suits brands whose subscription revenue already justifies enterprise tooling.
Smile.io started in 2012 as Sweet Tooth in Kitchener-Waterloo, Ontario, and rebranded in 2017. It is the largest ecommerce loyalty provider by program count, with more than 100,000 active programs and over 100 million members.
Points, referrals and VIP tiers are quick to launch, and it holds both of Shopify’s app certifications. For a store launching its first loyalty program after the holidays, Smile is the easiest place to start.
LoyaltyLion was founded in London in 2012 and works with more than 10,000 brands. It has been an exclusive Shopify Plus loyalty partner and is rated the top loyalty platform for mid-market brands on G2.
Its strength is segmentation and data: brands can see which members are most valuable and tailor rewards accordingly, and it supports programs that span several stores and markets.
Rivo launched in 2021 and is built only for Shopify, using metafields, Shopify Functions and native theme extensions. It is bootstrapped with no outside VC funding and runs loyalty and referrals for more than 7,000 brands, including HexClad, Kitsch, Caraway and Pier 1.
It has a free plan, a 4.9-star app rating from more than 2,400 reviews, and newer features such as subscription loyalty, cashback and an AI assistant.
Smartrr combines subscriptions with loyalty, referrals, memberships and SMS in one app, so subscribers earn rewards for staying and points can be spent on subscription products.
Pricing starts at $99 a month plus 1% of subscriber GMV. Running both programs in one place avoids duplicated customer data, which helps smaller teams.
Appstle Subscriptions charges no transaction fees on any plan, with a free tier and paid plans from $10 a month, and still covers bundles, build-a-box, a customer portal and cancellation flows.
It has thousands of reviews on the Shopify App Store and is the best value pick for stores testing subscribe-and-save for the first time after the holidays.
Yotpo Loyalty runs points, VIP tiers and referrals inside the wider Yotpo suite, so brands already using Yotpo reviews or SMS can reward reviews and target members without stitching tools together.
That shared data is the reason to choose it. Stores without other Yotpo products will usually find Smile or Rivo simpler.
Consumables like coffee, supplements and skincare suit subscriptions. Fashion, gifts and home goods suit loyalty. Many brands run both, either with two specialist apps or an all-in-one like Smartrr.
Check whether you can enroll BFCM customers automatically, give them a points welcome bonus, or offer a subscription upgrade in post-purchase flows.
Compare monthly fees and transaction fees together. A 1% fee on subscription GMV can outweigh a cheaper monthly plan once volume grows.
Look for skip, swap, delay and pause options and cancellation flows that ask why. These keep more subscribers than discounts alone.
Points balances, renewal dates and tier status should flow into Klaviyo or your SMS tool so every message can use them.
We compared tools on subscription and loyalty features, cancellation prevention, Shopify integration depth, pricing, scale and recent company changes, using vendor sites, Shopify App Store listings and press coverage. Facts were checked in November 2026. Read more about how we research and rank.
Recharge is the most established, Loop Subscriptions is strongest on cancellation prevention, and Appstle is the best value with no transaction fees.
Smile.io is easiest to launch, LoyaltyLion suits larger brands, and Rivo offers the most design control for Shopify-only stores.
Yes. Recharge announced its acquisition of Skio on April 30, 2026, in a deal reported at $105 million in cash. Skio continues to operate as a Recharge company.
Yes. Enrolling BFCM buyers with a welcome points bonus gives them a reason to make a second purchase at full price in the quiet weeks after the holidays.
Start with Recharge or Loop Subscriptions for replenishment, and Smile.io or LoyaltyLion for rewards. If you want help running them, see our list of post-holiday ecommerce retention agencies.