Last updated: November 21, 2026
The top post-holiday ecommerce retention agencies in 2027 are Sticky Digital, a female-founded Klaviyo Platinum agency in San Diego that won Yotpo’s North American retention agency award in 2023 and 2024, Underground Ecom, the London agency named Klaviyo’s EMEA Partner of the Year for 2025, and Flowium, a Klaviyo Elite partner trusted by more than 1,000 brands. Chronos Agency, Electriq and PAASE round out the strongest options.
Black Friday and Cyber Monday bring in thousands of first-time buyers at a discount. Most never buy again. A retention agency builds the post-purchase, replenishment, win-back and loyalty programs that turn that holiday cohort into second orders in January and February, when ad costs drop and the people you just paid to acquire are still paying attention. For in-house teams, our list of ecommerce email and SMS marketing agencies covers more options.
| Agency | Base | Founded | Klaviyo Tier |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sticky Digital | San Diego, California | 2019 | Platinum Master |
| Underground Ecom | London, UK | 2017 | Elite Master |
| Flowium | North America (remote) | Not disclosed | Elite Master |
| Chronos Agency | Singapore | 2017 | Elite Master |
| Electriq | California | 2018 | Elite |
| PAASE | Milton Keynes, UK | 2019 | Elite Master |
| Alchemy Worx | New York, New York | 2001 | Platinum Master |
| Growth Gurus | Australia | 2018 | Elite Master |
| Email Kong | London, UK | 2021 | Platinum Master |
| Simplistic | New York, New York | 2013 | Platinum Master |
Sticky Digital is a female-founded retention marketing agency in San Diego that works only on email, SMS, loyalty and subscription programs for Shopify and DTC brands. It does no paid acquisition or SEO, which keeps its team focused on what happens after the first order.
It is a Klaviyo Platinum Master partner and won Yotpo’s Best Retention Marketing Agency award for North America in both 2023 and 2024. Clients typically attribute 35% to 50% of store revenue to email and SMS, and the agency’s loyalty and subscription work makes it a strong fit for brands turning BFCM buyers into members.
Underground Ecom was founded in London in 2017 and holds Klaviyo’s top Elite Master tier. Klaviyo named it EMEA Agency Partner of the Year for 2025, and its clients include AG1, Huda Beauty, Osprey, Simba Sleep and Virgin Experience Days.
The agency is part of the Supergroup network and serves brands in the US, UK, Spain and France. Its work with AG1 rebuilt a global CRM setup so email became a steady revenue driver rather than a support channel, the same shift most brands need after a heavy holiday quarter.
Flowium is a full-service email and lifecycle marketing agency and Klaviyo Elite partner trusted by more than 1,000 brands, including True Classic, Dr. Squatch and RSVLTS. It handles strategy, copy, design and Klaviyo setup end to end, so lean teams can hand over the whole program.
It is an Inc. 5000 honoree, and its team covers SMS, push and list growth alongside email, so a post-holiday program can run across channels from one brief. One client credits Flowium with $300,000 to $400,000 a month in email revenue.
Chronos Agency was founded in 2017, is headquartered in Singapore with an office in Sydney, and is a Klaviyo Elite Master partner. It has served more than 500 brands with 80+ lifecycle specialists and reports more than $400 million in client revenue generated.
It works across email, SMS and push for brands doing $10 million to $500 million a year, including The Oodie and Qure Skincare. Its Singapore and Sydney teams make it a natural fit for Asia-Pacific brands, and it works with brands in North America and Europe as well.
Electriq was founded in 2018 by Brandon Amoroso as a Shopify Plus agency specializing in retention, and it became a DRINKS company in 2022. It describes itself as a retention-as-a-service agency covering email, SMS, loyalty, subscriptions and the site experience around them.
Recharge named it Innovation Partner of the Year in 2022, which makes it a strong pick for brands converting holiday buyers into subscribers. Clients have included Kitsch, Chomps, florence by mills, Health-Ade and Soylent.
PAASE was founded in 2019 near Milton Keynes and was the first UK agency to reach Klaviyo Platinum Master status, then the first Elite Master partner headquartered in EMEA. It also works in Bloomreach and Mapp for brands outside the Klaviyo ecosystem.
Clients include Dr Martens, Laura Ashley, Curlsmith, Wattbike and Union Coffee. Its PAASE AI tooling helps segment and time post-purchase messages, useful when a holiday cohort needs different treatment from long-standing customers.
Alchemy Worx has run retention programs since 2001, making it the most experienced agency on this list. Headquartered in New York with team members across the US, the Philippines and Mexico City, it is a Klaviyo Platinum Master partner and serves more than 100 brands.
Its niche is data-led reactivation: finding lapsed customers worth winning back and testing what brings them back profitably. That matters in February, when a large share of the holiday cohort starts to look lapsed.
Growth Gurus is an Australian retention agency and Klaviyo Elite Master partner that has spent more than eight years on one platform and one outcome: keeping customers and growing lifetime value through email, SMS, loyalty and data.
Clients include Blundstone, T2, My Muscle Chef, Mingle Seasoning and [yellow tail]. It offers a free retention audit, a useful first step for brands reviewing BFCM results before planning Q1.
Email Kong was started in London in 2021 by Bogdan Mihalache and is a Klaviyo Master Platinum partner in the top 2.5% of Klaviyo partners worldwide. It sits on Klaviyo’s Partner Advisory Council and reports more than $59 million attributed to Klaviyo across 140+ brands.
It is also a Loop Subscriptions partner and runs email, SMS and the subscription program as one system, so the welcome flow, the replenishment reminder and the subscription offer all come from the same team.
Simplistic is a New York ecommerce agency, one of the 12 original members of the Shopify Plus Partner Program, and holds both Shopify Plus Platinum and Klaviyo Platinum status. Its retention team manages 30+ Klaviyo clients across beauty, wellness, fashion, food, pets and home goods.
It is built for mid-market and enterprise brands doing $50 million to $500 million in GMV, and offers loyalty, referral, subscription and direct mail program management alongside email and SMS, with the full site team behind it when retention needs a storefront change.
Agencies that only do retention, such as Sticky Digital or Email Kong, tend to go deeper on flows, segmentation and loyalty. Full-service agencies like Simplistic help when retention depends on site or checkout changes.
Ask how they segment BFCM first-time buyers from loyal customers. Good agencies build a separate post-purchase path for discount buyers, with education first and offers later, instead of blasting everyone with another sale.
Second orders often come from a loyalty program or a subscribe-and-save offer. Check whether the agency has partner status with your loyalty and subscription tools.
Look for agencies that report repeat purchase rate, time to second order and returning customer revenue in Shopify, not just Klaviyo-attributed revenue.
Some agencies work month to month, others want six or twelve months. If you want help with the post-holiday window first, ask for an audit or a short project before a retainer.
We compared agencies on retention focus, Klaviyo partner tier, client roster, loyalty and subscription experience, awards and how they handle first-time buyer cohorts, using agency sites, partner directories and public reviews. Facts were checked in November 2026. Read more about how we research and rank.
A retention agency plans and runs the channels that bring existing customers back, mainly email, SMS, loyalty and subscriptions, including welcome, post-purchase, replenishment and win-back flows.
BFCM brings in many first-time buyers at a discount. Turning even a small share of them into repeat customers in January and February costs far less than acquiring new customers at peak ad prices.
Most charge monthly retainers. Smaller agencies start around $2,500 to $5,000 a month, while full-service programs for large brands run $10,000 a month and up.
It is the highest tier in Klaviyo’s agency partner program, awarded on client results, certifications and the volume of brands an agency manages on Klaviyo.
Pick Sticky Digital for a retention-only team, Underground Ecom for global brands, and Flowium for flexible full-service email. Then make sure the tools behind them are ready: see our lists of loyalty and rewards apps for Shopify and Shopify subscription apps.