Last updated: November 15, 2026
Short answer: Etsy is the better first marketplace for most makers: anyone can open a shop the same day, buyers come specifically for handmade and personalised items, and fees on lower-priced items are usually lower. Amazon Handmade suits makers with proven, higher-priced products who can pass Amazon’s artisan application, want access to Amazon’s huge customer base and Prime shipping through FBA, and prefer one flat 15% fee.
Both are marketplaces for handmade goods, but they work very differently. Etsy is open to anyone and charges several small fees. Amazon Handmade is invitation by application, vets that items are genuinely handmade, and charges a single referral fee.
| Factor | Etsy | Amazon Handmade |
|---|---|---|
| Getting started | Open a shop the same day | Application and artisan review, can take days to weeks |
| Main selling fee | 6.5% transaction fee on item plus shipping | 15% referral fee (minimum $0.30 per item) on total including shipping |
| Listing fee | $0.20 per listing, renewed every 4 months or on sale | None |
| Payment processing | 3% + $0.25 (US) | Included in referral fee |
| Monthly fee | None (optional Etsy Plus) | Professional plan fee waived for approved Handmade sellers |
| Advertising | Etsy Ads (pay per click) and Offsite Ads (12% to 15% per attributed sale) | Amazon Sponsored Products (pay per click) |
| Fulfillment | You ship, or use partners | Ship yourself or use Fulfillment by Amazon |
| What you can sell | Handmade, vintage, craft supplies, your own designs (incl. disclosed POD) | Genuinely handmade items only, in approved categories |
| Buyer mindset | Looking for unique, personalised, handmade | Convenience and fast delivery, comparing with mass-made items |
Etsy charges a $0.20 listing fee, a 6.5% transaction fee and 3% plus $0.25 payment processing in the US. Amazon Handmade charges a flat 15% referral fee, with no listing fee, no separate processing fee, and the $39.99 Professional plan fee waived once you are approved.
Worked example (no Offsite Ads):
Without ads, Etsy’s base fees are lower at every price point. The comparison changes when Etsy’s Offsite Ads apply: an attributed sale adds 12% to 15% on Etsy, which can push the total above Amazon’s 15%. Amazon has its own costs too, including FBA fees if you use it and pay-per-click ads that most Amazon sellers need to rank.
Winner: Etsy on base fees; it depends on Offsite Ads exposure.
Etsy has no approval step: verify your identity and payment details and start listing. Amazon Handmade requires an application describing how you make your products, and Amazon’s team reviews whether items are genuinely handmade. Resellers, most print on demand and mass-produced items are not accepted.
Winner: Etsy for ease of entry.
Etsy buyers come looking for unique, handmade, vintage and personalised items, which suits gifts and custom work. Etsy reported around 87 million active buyers in 2026. Amazon’s audience is far larger, but Handmade products appear alongside mass-produced alternatives, so you compete more on price, reviews and delivery speed. Amazon does not publish Handmade-specific buyer numbers.
Winner: Etsy for handmade intent, Amazon for raw reach.
On Etsy you ship orders yourself or through partners such as print on demand providers and shipping software. Amazon Handmade sellers can use Fulfillment by Amazon to store stock in Amazon warehouses and offer Prime delivery, which can lift conversion for ready-made items but does not suit one-off or made-to-order pieces.
Winner: Amazon for fast delivery on stocked products.
Etsy gives you a shop page with banner, about section and policies, plus some ways to build a following. Amazon Handmade offers an artisan profile but keeps the experience closer to standard Amazon product pages.
Winner: Etsy.
Choose Etsy if you are starting out, make personalised or one-of-a-kind items, sell under about $40, or want to build a recognisable shop. Choose Amazon Handmade if your products are proven, priced higher, can be stocked in quantity, and benefit from Prime delivery. Many makers start on Etsy and add Amazon Handmade once their bestsellers are clear.
Etsy is the easier, cheaper and more handmade-focused place to start, and Amazon Handmade is a strong second channel for proven, higher-priced products that suit FBA. For full fee detail see our Etsy fees breakdown, for other options read our best Etsy alternatives and Etsy vs Shopify, and find more guides on the Etsy Sellers hub.
Amazon Handmade is better for proven, higher-priced handmade products that benefit from Amazon’s reach and Prime delivery. Etsy is better for most makers starting out because there is no application and buyers come specifically for handmade items.
Amazon Handmade charges a 15% referral fee on the total sale including shipping, with a minimum of $0.30 per item. There is no listing fee, and the $39.99 Professional plan fee is waived for approved Handmade sellers.
Without advertising, yes. Etsy’s base fees come to roughly 10% to 12% of a typical sale versus Amazon Handmade’s flat 15%. Sales attributed to Etsy Offsite Ads add 12% to 15%, which can make Etsy more expensive on those orders.
Yes. Many makers list on both. Multichannel tools can help sync inventory, and you should keep prices and policies consistent across both marketplaces.